FFN - Non-Operative Management of Fragility Hip Fracture

 
Outcomes following non-operative management of hip fracture may have improved with better nursing and geriatrician-based care, and management of pain, nutrition and skin. With an increasingly old, frail and cognitively impaired population presenting with hip fracture either now or, for some countries in the future, there are questions to be asked about what, if any, are the indications for non-operative management. Hip fracture is not the only fragility fracture where non-operative management is relevant, but it is the commonest, the populations are similar within and across countries, and there is relatively little controversy about the effectiveness of surgical management. 

These questions are not purely clinical – the answers will be strongly influenced by local societal and medical values and ethical frameworks, resource availability, and national and local structures.
 
We ask that you complete the survey thinking about your local practice in general. There will always be individual contexts that we cannot capture in a survey such as this - you may wish to add detail in the other comments sections. 
 
This survey seeks to explore regional variation in how decisions are made. All answers are completely anonymous. The results will be reported back to Fragility Fracture Network members and will inform future consensus statements on best practice.
 
The survey takes around 5 minutes or less to complete.

Thank you for your help.
 
Iain Moppett & Lynn McNicoll
Co-chairs, Peri-operative Specialist Interest Group
RESPONDENT and POPULATION CHARACTERSTICS
1.What is your specialty?
2.In which country do you work?
3.Which of the following best describes where you work?
4.Approximately how many people are admitted to your institution with hip fracture each year?
NON-OPERATIVE MANAGEMENT: NUMBERS
5.Approximately what proportion (%) of people admitted to your institution with fragility hip fracture undergo surgery? 
(i.e. 100 means everyone has surgery, 75 means 75% have surgery, 25% don't).
6.Is this based on systematic audit / data collection or a ‘best guess’?
7.Approximately what proportion (%) of people with fragility hip fracture in your catchment population do you estimate are admitted to your hospital / institution?
Please enter 'not known' if unable to estimate.
NON-OPERATIVE MANAGEMENT: DECISION MAKING
8.What are the common reasons for deciding not to operate on hip fracture patient at your institution?
Please select all that apply.
9.If insufficient resources at your institution are a common reason which of these do you think are important?
Never
Rarely
Sometimes
Frequently
Always
Availability of beds
Availability of surgeons
Availability of anaesthetists
Availability of nurses
Availability of operating time
Availability of implants / equipment for surgery
SURGICAL FACTORS
10.Does the pattern of hip fracture affect your decision to not operate?
CHRONIC MEDICAL CONDITIONS
Would any of the following conditions influence the decision to offer non-operative management?
11.THE PATIENT'S COGNITIVE STATUS

The definitions of severe / moderate / mild are left to the respondent's clinical discretion
12.FRAILTY
13.CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE

The definitions of severe / moderate are left to the respondent's clinical discretion

Please select all that apply
14.MALIGNANCY / CANCER
15.CHRONIC KIDNEY DISEASE
ACUTE MEDICAL CONDITIONS

Would any of the following acute medical conditions influence the decision to offer non-operative management? 

All of these conditions might prompt delay but the question is about deciding not to offer surgery at all. 
16.COGNITIVE FUNCTION

The definitions of severe / moderate / mild are left to the respondent's clinical discretion
17.ACUTE KIDNEY INJURY

This question is about not operating at all, not a clinical decision to delay.
18.INFECTION

This question is about not operating at all, not a clinical decision to delay.

Please select all that apply. 

19.RISK STRATIFICATION TOOLS

Do you use any risk stratification tools to support a decision to operate or not?
Please select all that apply
20.LIFE EXPECTANCY
Does the patient's expected life expectancy influence a decision to operate or not?
Please select all that apply
SOCIOECONOMIC FACTORS
21.Does cost of treatment ever influence the decision to operate?
Never
Rarely
Sometimes
Frequently
Always
Insufficient hospital resources
Inability / unwillingness of patient / family to meet costs
INSTITUTIONAL / SURGEON / ANAESTHETIST FACTORS

Do any of the following influence your decision to operate?
22.Perceived or actual risk to institution if the patient were to die?
23.If yes, where would these risks come from?
Never
Rarely
Sometimes
Frequently
Always
Media
Hospital regulators (outside the hospital / institution)
Police / law enforcement
Coroner
24.Perceived or actual risk to an individual clinician if the patient were to die?
25.If yes, where would these risks come from?
Never
Rarely
Sometimes
Frequently
Always
Media
Hospital regulators (outside the hospital / institution)
Hospital senior managers (inside the hospital / institution)
Police / law enforcement
Coroner
Colleagues / peers (e.g. morbidity and mortality meetings)
DECISION MAKING PROCESSES
26.In the context of a person with a hip fracture able to make their own decisions, how important are the following in deciding whether an operation should be performed
Not at all important
Not very important
Somewhat important
Very important
Extremely important
The thoughts and wishes of the person with the hip fracture
The thoughts and wishes of the family
The cultural background or religious views of the person with the hip fracture
The professional judgement of the clinicians
27.In the context of a person with a hip fracture who is not able to make their own decisions (for instance because of confusion), how important are the following in deciding whether an operation should be performed
Not at all important
Not very important
Somewhat important
Very important
Extremely important
The previously expressed thoughts and wishes of the person with the hip fracture
The thoughts and wishes of the family
The cultural background or religious views of the person with the hip fracture
The professional judgement of the clinicians
28.Do you have any other comments you wish to make about non-operative management of hip fracture?