Workplace based assessments, Video based assessments and Video Elogbook

We value your experiences and opinions on the use of the current written workplace-based assessments (WBA), video-based assessments (VBA) and Video elogbook (VEL).
VBA is the process of trainer assessment of operating with the aid of video recording, with the same process as the current procedure-based assessment (PBA).
Video Elogbook is the concept of operative storage of a trainee's videos, to be shared along the training pathway. 

Question Title

1. What is your grade: (Required.)

Question Title

2. What is your surgical specialty (or intended) (Required.)

Question Title

3. What is your region? (Required.)

Question Title

4. Have you previously used the ISCP portfolio? (Required.)

Question Title

5. How many WBAs did you complete in the last year before last ARCP? (Required.)

0 100
Clear
i We adjusted the number you entered based on the slider’s scale.

Question Title

6. What proportion do you estimate are completed immediately after the event? (Give as %) (Required.)

0 100
Clear
i We adjusted the number you entered based on the slider’s scale.

Question Title

7. Do you believe inaccurate WBA recording takes place?*


*Inaccurate completion includes any form of inaccurate or misrepresentative entry, such as self-completion of your trainer's rating, writing/ dictating trainer comments yourself, recording an activity that did not take place, exaggerating/ overstating activity, trainer not observing the activity, or any other deviation from the WBA's intended use (Required.)

Question Title

8. What proportion do you believe are not signed off honestly? (Required.)

0 100
Clear
i We adjusted the number you entered based on the slider’s scale.

Question Title

9. Have you ever been aware of a trainer validating (signing off) a WBA without observing the learning episode? (Required.)

Question Title

10. Have you ever been aware of a trainer allowing a trainee to make comments/ ratings on their behalf in a WBA? (Required.)

Question Title

11. Have you ever been aware of a trainer allowing a trainee to sign off a WBA on their behalf (e.g. permitting the trainee to access their ISCP account)? (Required.)

Question Title

12. The number of WBAs I have to complete for ARCP is achievable (Required.)

Question Title

13. WBAs hold educational value as tools to aid learning (Required.)

Question Title

14. WBAs are useful as tools to assess competence (Required.)

Question Title

15. I have personally had meaningful training discussions with my trainers based on WBAs (Required.)

Question Title

16. Do you feel confident that the current WBAs will equip you to be ready for CCT? (Required.)

Question Title

17. Do you have the ability to video record any of your operating (Required.)

Question Title

18. Have you video recorded yourself operating (Required.)

Question Title

19. What proportion of cases do you record and store (Required.)

0 100
Clear
i We adjusted the number you entered based on the slider’s scale.

Question Title

20. Have you used operative recording for reflection and/or trainer discussions after a case with a supervisor? (Required.)

Question Title

21. What proportion of your recorded videos do you use for analysis with your trainer? (Required.)

0 100
Clear
i We adjusted the number you entered based on the slider’s scale.

Question Title

22. If the technology was available, would you engage in VBA? (Required.)

Question Title

23. Should video assessment form part of your ARCP process? (Required.)

Question Title

24. Would VBA be useful as an educational tool? (Required.)

Question Title

25. Would you prefer VBAs or written WBAs if given an option (Required.)

Written Equal mix Video
Clear
i We adjusted the number you entered based on the slider’s scale.

Question Title

26. Should video assessment be used in place of WBA for assessment? (Required.)

Question Title

27. I would be worried about the medico-legal implications of recorded videos (Required.)

Question Title

28. My performance may be affected by knowing I am being recorded (Required.)

Question Title

29. I would be worried that having my videos available to trainers may have a negative impact on my training opportunities (Required.)

Question Title

30. Do you feel confident in the current WBAs in demonstrating competence (Required.)

Question Title

31. Have you experienced difficulty in demonstrating competence when rotating between units? (Required.)

Question Title

32. A Video E-logbook would be useful as evidence of competency when transferring between units (Required.)

Question Title

33. A Video E-logbook would be useful as evidence of competency within the same unit (Required.)

Question Title

34. A Video E-logbook would allow me to progress faster when transferring between units (Required.)

Question Title

35. I would be concerned regarding sharing my operative videos with trainers/colleagues (Required.)

Question Title

36. What barriers do you feel face the real world-use of operative video assessment

Question Title

37. Do you consent for your anonymised responses to be used in research which may be published? (Required.)

Question Title

38. If you are interested in participating in a UK pilot study for VBA please leave your email below (Required.)

T